I am sad to say but The Last Jedi is an action packed sugar rush that crashes and burns after careful consideration.
Whereas I gave a pass at Force Awakens retelling of A New Hope given the respect that JJ gave to the source material I am afraid that I can’t do the same to The Last Jedi. In story telling there is an internal consistency rule that states that authors should always obey the self imposed rules that they established for their world. In many instances The Last Jedi is willfully ignores those rules in order to serve the plot. This is perhaps one of the main problems with Rian Johnson’s script. It aims at creating dramatic tension at the cost of internal consistency. Even some of the advancement in the Jedi mythology puts into question some of the main plot points of its own movie. Furthermore, some of the characters decisions are well out of character. This was something that JJ did very well in Force Awakens, Han Solo felt like Han Solo, but in Johnson script, Luke was unrecognizable. He idealism and optimism are long gone, left in the dust of post modernism. Old age, failure and cynicism transformed this character in something unappealing, something that is not Luke Skywalker. I can understand the change in character if the rational is well articulated, but Johnson script does not take the time to do so. The words of Robert McKee sounds very true on this point: in his book Dialogue he stresses the importance of writers writing from the point of view of their characters. The question is not what would I do if I were this character, but rather what would my character do…absent any explanation the character feels alien and the magic of disbelief is broken.
On the bright side, some of the scene are just beautiful to look at. The concept design are in good Star Wars form and Mr. Willian score is adequate. However, the constant plot holes, fan service scene, check box for character diversity, and over active editing damper your mood; not to mention artistic decisions that impacted the course of Star Wars mythology.
What a missed opportunity and to think that Mr. Johnson is in charge of bringing a new trilogy…Star Wars is not in dextrous hands.